1 - Limited scientific description of the measurement methodology available
2 - Comprehensive scientific description of the measurement methodology, report on limited
validation, and limited measurement series user guide
3 - Score 2 + paper on methodology published; Validation report available from data collector
or in grey literature; comprehensive user guidance is available
4 - Score 4 + comprehensive scientific description available from data provider; report on
inter comparison available; paper on validation published; user guide available from data
provider includes details of validation and characterisation
5 - Score 4 + comprehensive scientific description maintained by data provider; report on data
assessment results exists; user guide is regularly updated with updates on product and
validation; description on practical implementation is available from data provider
6 - Score 5 + journal papers on product updates are and more comprehensive validation and
validation of quantitative uncertainty estimates are published; operations concept
regularly updated
1 - None
2 - Limited steps taken towards assuring traceability and comparability; limited information
exists on systematic and random measurement uncertainties
3 - Score 2 + limited traceabaility and comparability assured; comprehensive documentation on
measurement uncertainties present and methods for routine quality monitoring defined
4 - Score 3 + steps required to establish traceability are defined; (inter)comparison against
corresponding measurements in organised campaigns available; quantitative estimates of
uncertainty available and routine monitoring partially implemented
5 - Score 4 + traceability partly established; measurements regularly compared to a measurement
of similar or greater traceability; systematic uncertainties removed and uncertainty
estimates are partially traceable; routine quality monitoring fully implemented
6 - Score 5 + traceability established; measurements are regularly compared to other traceable
measurements to verify; comprehensive validation of the quantitative uncertainty estimates
that are fully traceable; routine monitoring in place with results noted in meta data or
documentation
1 - Restricted availability through request
2 - Data avaliable from originator
3 - Data and documentation publically available from originator, feedback collated,
irregular updates, initial versioning and local archival
4 - Data and documentation available through a recognised data portal; feedback mechanism
considers published analyses; version control formalized, rocbust archival on multiple media
5 - Source data, code and metadata archived and available upon request; established feedback
mechanism; regular update cycle; fully established version control; data archival at
recognized national or international long-term repository
6 - Score 5 + no data access restrictions; active consideration of user feedback; data available
in initial version for near-real time applications; all versions retained, indexed and
available through a recognised repository
1 - None
2 - Benefit for research applications identified; Potential public and commercial opportunities identified